May 1838
The reminiscence's narrator was taken with scarlet fever, with a two months' sickness.
Nation and worldGrade A · 1 independent source
The evidence
“Fortunately for us until September, 1838, when we were taken down with the fever and ague, we were generally well except I was taken in May 1838 with the Scarlet fever. I had a long two months' sickness with this.”
1900-caswell-reminiscences/07-fort-atkinson-and-early-janesville.md, PDF pp. 3–27
Caswell, Lucien Bonaparte. The Reminiscences of the Hon. L. B. Caswell. Written at Fort Atkinson, Wis., 1914–1916; four-column newspaper reprint, newspaper and date unidentified. University of Wisconsin-Madison Libraries.
Grade A: Found on a page of one of our sources